Deafness, like most things is far from black and white. Hearing impairment differs from person to person and thus there is really a whole spectrum that spans from those who associate themselves as Capital “D” Deaf and have forgone any kind of assistitive hearing aid or Cochlear implant device because they are happy living in a world without sound (at least as most people know it). They are not oral and Sign Language is their primary language and method of communicating, they often goto Deaf-only schools and Colleges and only have Deaf friends. Deaf people have great pride in their unique culture and can be quite protective and rebellious when hearing people try to impose their ways or views upon Deaf culture. Deafness is not viewed as a disability but rather a difference in perspective that the hearing world does not offer.
At the other end of the spectrum you’ll get Hearing Impaired types which may range from a slight or temporary loss of hearing that doesn’t really significantly affect the day-to-day living of that person, they tend to associate within the hearing world and are not familiar with Deaf culture. They may be late-deafened adults who wear hearing aids or people that have been given Cochlear Implants when they were a baby and so have developed an auditory brain and coping mechanisms that rival their hearing peers. They will usually be oral which means they speak and write in English and do not know Sign Language (or whatever is the dominantly spoken language of their country of course). Hearing impaired people typically have some degree of lip-reading skill and often their slight disability is invisible to others except for the occasional missed word or sentence in noisy situations.
In the middle of the spectrum I would put those that are “Hard-of-Hearing” or possibly they associate themselves as a lower-case “d” deaf. These poor guys probably have the biggest challenge to overcome because they may have moderate-to-severe hearing loss but still try to be oral and participate in the hearing world or they may perhaps be a mix of Sign language/Oral and dip in and out of the Deaf world. The Hard-of-Hearing (or HoH) struggle a lot to keep up in the hearing world because speech perception is one of the first things to take its toll when you have severe hearing loss but there is still access to a lot of sound via hearing aids/Cochlear Implants. HoH may or may not associate with the Deaf Community and it often depends on the family background, for example children that are HoH and have hearing parents may not have been raised with Sign language and will have gone to Mainstream schools with the help of note-takers. HoH people can be pretty isolated as they get excluded when it comes to hearing social events and they may find it difficult to communicate with Deaf people as they do not known Sign Language. That said, there have been many cases of HoH & orally raised deaf people that make a transition over to the Deaf community later in life when they start to learn sign language either by meeting the right kind of patient and understanding people or taking lessons on their own initiative, but then there are many that do not and live out a life feeling different and excluded…
Now for those who are still reading, hopefully you’ll have the beginnings of a better picture about what “Deafness” is and indeed how being “Deaf” can differ from being “deaf”… If you’re wondering, I currently feel that my own cultural situation lands somewhere between the “Hoh” and “Hearing” end of the spectrum as I never was taught how to Sign and I have fared pretty well in the Hearing world via lip-reading and contextual prediction of what people are saying.
At camp, there were moments of frustration when I had difficulty with “unlearning” the English order of structuring sentences in favor of ASL’s. For example in spoken and written English a typical sentence may have an Object-Subject-Verb order of phrasing whereas American Sign Language tends toward Subject-Verb-Object. This fact alone meant that even if I knew what all the hand signs meant, I was not easily able to understand if the signer was asking me a question or telling me an answer with in a conversation…
Often-times we ended up just having someone type into my laptop the ASL dialog and then I could read and follow along. This turned out to be the best method at least when the discussion was moving along swiftly and I wouldn’t have been able to keep up if we hadn’t had done this so I am of course very grateful for everyone that took turns in being my interpreter.
Overall Having a solid two-week exposure to the Deaf end of the spectrum has given me a glimpse of what it’s like to not having to strain and struggle to hear conversation and I really enjoyed the fact that I could start relaxing into an easier and more fluid visual method of communication. I feel lucky that I was with a bunch of great and really patient campers that gave me a real cram course in American Sign Language (ASL). I would say that this has been a pivotal moment for me as I really enjoy signing and participating in the deaf community. The question is really whether I can still focus on my own music and personal development and keep investing time into learning ASL and teaching… I think it can be done but may see me dipping in and out of both ends of the spectrum. I’d love to combine both the hearing and deaf worlds into one big moment though and have ideas on how to proceed with this…
Back on topic though, now that we have an understanding of Deafness, we need to next ask.. What is “Music”?
Yeah, I don’t think there’s a choice to make really. We can all speak as many languages as we want and Sign Language is just another one, you can learn it as I learned English and communicate with whoever you want. I know these are two different situations and I understand that you felt relieved and comfortable signing but I don’t see it as if you have to stick with one of those realities and ignore the other, so I’m all in favor of you trying to combine both worlds
I agree with you up to a point Chowy
Definitely we can learn different languages, I was able to learn quite a bit of German myself at school when I was younger but my hearing was better back then. With my hearing deteriorating, I can barely make out English these days let alone another unfamiliar language (spoken that is), learning a new language would be nearly impossible for me now. However Sign is different because it is all visual and not spoken so it is far more accessible.
Here is to combining both worlds though! Hell yea
Chowy, I’m with you on this one! Myles, another well written and insightful post. I hope you keep up the signing studies so you can put yourself in the position of choosing which world to dive into and when.
Can’t wait to hear more
Myles,
You did a pretty good job in explaining the various groups within the Deaf community! I wonder how you came about to this information? From a friend or based on your own observations up to now? There’s a good book that explains the concept of deaf culture and but is a very dry read…if you’re interested…it’s called “Understanding Deaf Culture: In Search of Deafhood” by Paddy Ladd (he’s a Brit
)…Once you read the book, you’ll understand that it really is hard to summarize the Deaf community into three groups…like human nature, we have many boxes we identify with…there’s no black and white, even though we might see some extremes in individuals…
When you said capital “D” Deaf do not use any assistive listening devices, nor speak…well, I do use hearing aids (sporadically and when needed) and can speak (still do, to communicate with hearing people)…so I do not fit into that category…yet I consider myself a member of the Deaf community, as I’m a teacher of the Deaf, have Deaf friends, and get passionately involved in Deaf politics
, thus I’m not “HoH or lower case “d” deaf). Like I said earlier, no one is in a box itself…there’s always more to check…:-D…
Personally, I dislike the concept of capital and lower cases of the word deaf…it feels divisive within our own community. There have been situations or comments that people make that use these descriptives to make themselves look better and others bad. I think it would be best to throw it all out and come up with an inclusive terminology that includes all, yet embraces the differences amongst ourselves. Perhaps “Deaf community/Signing community”…People who sign, and then there are people who do not sign… Anyone that has a significant hearing loss is deaf, period! When speaking about the Deaf community, the word should be capitalized, as it is a culture in its own, as if you were talking about the British…you don’t write british…but if you use deaf as an adjective, then it should be lower case ie: “I am deaf in one ear.” I can go on and on about this issue…because I personally think this is why we have sooooooo many issues within our community…this impacts the view of cochlear implants, genetic engineering, and etc… Ultimately, if we are to discuss and measure deafness by science/audiology, then use the audiological terminology for that… Discuss culture? Use inclusive terminology, yet point out the differences…like “I am Deaf and interact with hearing people often” rather than “I’m Hard of Hearing and I only hang out with hearing people.”… Let me know if I’m not clear on this…I’ll be more than happy to explain in person (more organic and natural that way)
…
Myles, I consider you a part of the Deaf community! Based from what I’ve read on your blog, you have metamorphosed your perception of yourself and think its a beautiful thing! I especially loved when you embraced the situation you were given and looked at it as a positive rather than negative! Like the saying “Everything happens for a reason”…from wanting an implant to fix your hearing, to accepting the fact that it will not be fixed and turning it to being actively involved in the Deaf community (Deaf Music Camp, the email correspondence between you and I, the ASL signing time, and many other things that have yet to come). I definitely do see many more things to come from you in the future, more so with bridging music with our community.
Multi-task! You can do it all…continue your personal development, focus on your music AND be a part of the Deaf community! It doesn’t have to be an either/or thing…it’s all about balance and remembering the core of who you are…as well as continuing the journey of life that will enhance your core…
Soooo sorry for the long comment…just that your blogs got me thinking and brought up many good topics/food for thought…I’ve discussed them with friends and it has brought out great discussions…
Looking forward to reading more about your journey into Deafhood and how you incorporate the hearing world/music into it…
~Oni
Haha, wow Oni your comment is almost as long as my blog post. Good work!
You raise a lot of really interesting points, I absolutely agree with you in regards to the whole “deafness is not black or white”. I prefer to think of it as a spectrum that encompasses a whole range of different hearing backgrounds and levels of immersions in Deaf Culture. I tried to highlight some of the extremes and also some of the middle ground in my post.
I am definitely going to try and adopt more “inclusive” terminology in my writing from now on because I really believe in the importance of unity and understanding between different cultures and even for those within the same culture. That’s one of the deep rooted agendas about my goal to start a Deaf Music Festival. Bring together often very segmented groups and let them mingle as one collective.
I hope we can discuss this further in person Oni! I need the ASL practice pretty bad